Yes and NO....Scotty was wonderful, and I'm not all that unhappy he won, but I think both James and Casey should have been there for the top 3. James should have been the winner IMO, because Scotty, being country, would do fine no matter what. I don't think any of the girls were as good as those 3 guys.

I am so happy to see  people from Friday Night Lights were nominated. In my opinion this is the best show on TV and maybe the best ever. The casting is perfection. Everyone should have been nominated, certainly supporting actore Taylor Kitsch and whoever plays Buddy Garrity. If you aren't watching this show, you should...more

Diddy wants Diddy's face all over the tv, that's what Diddy wants. Not happening if anybody cares about the show after Simon leaves. And it's becoming apparant that nobody does. (well, there's always me)

That's ridiculous! Carrie is the first woman to win back to back Entertainer of the Year titles...I suppose they ranked Clarkson higher due to the same old  anti-country music bias.

Well, I'll tell you what, it's not Usher's CD I'm buying. It's Carrie's and Kellie's and Adam's and etc etc etc... And I'm from the 50's when they knew what music was!

Kellie was on in the season AFTER Carrie...I don't think whoever wrote this did his or her homework! Love them both! Kellie was so adorable..

I think Crystal is one of my favorite singers they've ever had, but mainly because she's the kind of singer whose album I'd like to buy. I also don't see the Lee thing..He bores me with his lack of personality, although he does have a great voice..Siobhan has been really badly treated by Simon, I think..For some reason...more

Gone With The Wind...The winner hands down in my book!  Glad to see you included Brokeback Mountain. One of my all time faves.